Professional engineers say the lack of maintenance of the drainage
infrastructure is to blame for continued stagnant water along
the East Coast and in South Georgetown.
While several areas have seen
water drain off, there are other communities that despite a brief
respite in the rainfall are not seeing any relief.
Melvin Sankies, President of the
Guyana Association of Professional Engineers (GAPE) believes there
must have been a breach of the Lamaha Conservancy and a crown
dam close to it. He said he has spoken with a fellow engineer
about his suspicions and is awaiting confirmation. "There
is no doubt there has been a breach to the crown dam, which has
affected areas such as Enterprise."
Sankies said there needs to be
a survey done by professionals to assess the situation and come
up with a short-term and long-term solution.
He also said that final year students
at the University of Guyana (UG) who are assigned to do projects
on drainage could not get any information out of the Hydrometeorological
Division. "There must be better co-operation between the
government, the private sector and UG so that institution can
do its work."
A retired engineer who was responsible
for servicing drainage pumps and technical services for Guysuco
on the East Coast has said that before nationalisation, sluices
such as the one close to the Ruimveldt Police Station were used
to drain water into the Demerara River. At that time he said the
canals were clear and water was diverted, using all the interconnected
waterways, into the river.
Providing that the sluices and
canals were in good working order half the water from the East
Coast could have been released.
He recalled two years ago, "I
had warned my colleagues to get the canals activated because the
time would come when the East Coast would need to be drained."
There were links to bring water through South, he said.
He said politics sometimes affected
engineers working on essential services such as desilting canals.
He said at one time politicians had stopped his brother who is
also an engineer from cleaning a critical canal. And during drainage
work at Mon Repos a politician along with the regional chairman
came and demanded to have the services of the drag line he was
using. But he told them that he was doing work which was saving
the lives on the coast.
"Georgetown is not properly
engineered... people do not realise where water should be drained,"
he said, "It is stupid to put water in South (Ruimveldt)
to be drained at Liliendaal." He noted that the water in
South should be drained through the sluices at Meadow Bank but
the canals leading there are blocked with weeds. The sluices there
are begging for water, he said.
"I am so annoyed and fed
up... but a lot of times I have told them about the drainage.
All the trenches are blocked with weeds. We don't need a rocket
scientist to say what the problem is. The flooding is understandable
but not to have people living in it.
"The East Coast is linked
to LBI where there are drainage systems to get water off the front
lands. Drainage pumps were set up to drain the front end but they
must drain the back before clearing the front. If you do a survey
of the square miles at the back into which the water must drain
one would see that one of the obvious things to do would be just
to tickle some of the canals to get the water in the canals running.
There is not always the need for a dragline. You can't not look
at the sluices everyday, because every high tide would bring in
sling, mud and silt that must be moved right away. You could just
tickle the sluice to let the water rush out which would wash the
sluice out," he said.
"The problem is our own fault.
On the estate the sluices and pumps are maintained in the dry
and wet weather. So it is the build up of bad practices over the
years that is coming back to confront us as a monster. Georgetown
is slackness, it needs sluices because it's going to take a hell
of a long time to pump water off."
The whole system was designed
for the canals to drain water off of the backlands so, "every
time I see weeds in the canals in South it grieves me."
He recalled that Phillip Allsop
former Chief Hydraulic Engineer was mostly correct in his article
about the situation. He referred to Allsop's words on the Harbour
Bridge and agreed that it restricts the flow of water and aggravates
siltation, But he added, "This is not the main problem. Every
high tide brings in mud and sand. This happens on a daily basis
therefore persons should be paid to look at the sluices everyday.
The estates used to pay people to watch at the sluices everyday
and find solutions. That man only has to make one prompt decision
per year and he can save millions. People may want to think that
these men who once lived in houses next to the sluices were wasting
time but they are essential. All these positions can provide jobs
for people who need them."
Another senior engineer who preferred
to remain anonymous said the cause of the floods stemmed from
the conservancy overtopping and bad drainage. He estimated that
there were some eight to ten sluices draining Georgetown in the
early 19th century.
He said what happens now is that
these are currently not functioning as they should; the storage
capacity for water has been reduced; the habits of the people
throwing food boxes in the drains, siltation and the maintenance
of drains are also to blame.
The engineer noted that people
are now living where water was stored on land just outside Kitty
such as Sophia. But noted there were no new canals to facilitate
the growth. "Students' reports have told me that there has
been a large volume of storage capacity lost by the filling of
canals."
The engineer who lives in South
Ruimveldt said that water is flowing into the basin from another
source.
"Part of the immediate problem
arises from roads in several areas acting as drains because of
a lack of maintenance and understanding. The verges are higher
than the roads but in the old days every hundred yards or so holes
were placed to let the water drain into the roadside drains."
"They should be doing what
was done in the past; call in professional engineers and let them
do the job. The President and ministers should not be walking
around the place talking. Let the engineers do the job and then
'buse them," he asserted.
In addition there is no data coming
from the Hydrometeorological Division for students. Data should
be freely given to students studying whether pumps at Liliendaal
could drain Georgetown. He said that the pumps such as those at
Liliendaal should be taking water off out of the Industry and
Turkeyen areas. He suggested the necessity to put in some more
pumping stations.
"We need data, plans, financial
aid for students and hydrometeorological information but the government
is not prepared to give free data. They must use students at UG
to do studies of this area."
Walter Willis, Technical Advisor
in the Ministry of Public Works said he would reserve his comments
until he has made a deeper assessment of the situation.
Charles Ceres, Head of Ground
Structure Engineering has said, "I am disappointed by the
level in response. I get the sense that the infrastructure was
not designed for that level of rainfall. 100% efficiency has not
been the case. Drainage and Irrigation is not my area and not
something I would want to comment on but I think they should be
mobilizing resources to get help to these persons."
[Editor's Note: Published first by Stabroek News on January 23,
2005 under a different title.]